What Does Your Industry’s Marketing Benchmark Tell You?

At some point, you’ve probably looked around at other companies in your industry and wondered if you’re spending anywhere close to the same on marketing as everyone else. It's a fair question, and a good benchmark can answer part of it. The trouble is that most people treat the answer like a target instead of a reference point.

We want to help you use it the right way, and that starts with knowing what a benchmark can and can't do.

Here's the short version. An industry average tells you what the typical company spends on its marketing budget. It doesn't tell you what you should spend, whether those companies spend well, or whether your business works like theirs. This post walks through how to pick the right comparison, adjust it for your situation, and carry it into a leadership conversation without getting led astray.

Start with what a benchmark really is

A marketing budget benchmark is an average. Researchers ask a large group of companies how much of their revenue they spend on marketing, sort the answers by industry, and publish the results. Each group mixes small companies with large ones, fast growers with flat ones, and businesses that sell through relationships with businesses that sell through search.

That mix is the whole story. The average describes the middle of a crowd, and you aren't necessarily standing in the middle.

Take two companies in the same industry. One sells to consumers through ads and local search, and the other sells to a handful of enterprise buyers through relationships. Both land inside the same industry average, yet their marketing budgets should look nothing alike.

Benchmarks tempt us because they feel safe. Matching the average is easy to defend in a meeting, even when it's the wrong call for your business. We understand the pull, and we'd rather you use the number as a question than as cover.

Four questions to ask before you trust any benchmark

Before you compare yourself to anything, put four questions to the source. A benchmark worth using can answer all of them.

  • Who's in the sample? Look at company size, business model, and region. A benchmark built mostly from companies ten times your size describes a different business.
  • What does it count? Some figures cover marketing alone, and others blend in sales. Many don't say whether salaries or a founder's time sit inside the number, so find out before you compare.
  • What are those companies trying to do? An average of companies chasing aggressive growth looks different from an average of companies protecting what they have.
  • How current is it? Budgets shift with the economy and with new channels, and a figure from several years ago may describe a different market.

If the source can't answer those questions, treat its number as a rough sketch. A sketch still helps, as long as you don't make payroll decisions with it.

Pick the right comparison set

Industry is a starting point, and your sales model matters just as much. In B2B, relationships and referrals drive most leads, so your sales line carries more of the load and your marketing line supports it. In B2C, marketing usually carries the lead generation. Our pages on revenue generation for B2B businesses and revenue generation for B2C businesses show how each model splits the work.

That means the same industry average can flatter one model and shortchange the other.

Sales cycle and margin matter too. A business with a long sales cycle has to fund marketing months before revenue shows up, and a business with thin margins has less room to spend at all. Write down your model, your cycle, and your margin next to your industry name, because that combination is your real comparison set.

Stage matters as well. A company still growing on personal effort can spend little and look fine for a while, and a company that has hit its ceiling needs to spend more just to move. Same industry, different stage, different right answer, which is the pattern behind why growth stalls.

Compare like with like

Once you've chosen your comparison set, compare numbers that measure the same thing. Most published benchmarks cover marketing alone, so set them against your marketing allocation, not your combined sales and marketing figure. If you haven't calculated yours yet, our post on your marketing budget as a percentage of revenue walks you through it, and our post on your sales allocation covers the other half.

Then run the calculation two ways. Work out a cash-only number, and work out an all-in number that includes your own time.

The cash-only version is the safer match for a published average, because you can rarely confirm that a survey counts anyone's time. The all-in version tells you what marketing really costs your business. If your cash-only number sits near the average while your all-in number sits well above it, you've learned something valuable: you're paying for marketing with your own calendar instead of your budget.

Use a range instead of a single number

A single percentage invites a single reaction: we're above it, or we're below it. A range gives you a better decision. Build one with three markers: the 7% floor that studies point to for businesses seeking consistent growth, your industry average, and the level your own growth goal requires.

The third marker is the one most teams skip.

Say your business brings in $3 million a year and your industry averages 9%. The 7% floor comes to $210,000 a year, and the average comes to $270,000. The $60,000 between them isn't a rule. It's the price tag on a conversation about how fast you want to grow.

Work out the third marker with the math in our post on your revenue generation commitment. Your goal minus your current revenue gives you the new revenue you need, your cost per customer tells you how many clients that takes, and the two together give you a budget. That budget might land above the average, and that's fine, because your goal sets the target and the average only offers a reference. Revisit all three markers every quarter, because your revenue, your goal, and your cost per customer all move, and a range that fit last quarter can miss this one.

Pair every benchmark with a return

A benchmark tells you what other companies spend. It can't tell you whether that spending works, and every average includes plenty of companies that waste money. Pair each comparison with your own return, starting with what each new customer costs you. Our guide to what makes a good marketing ROI helps you judge the result.

A company spending below the average with a healthy return is doing something right. A company spending above it with a poor return is paying for the privilege.

Once you know the right total, you still have to decide where it goes. Our guide to marketing budget allocation for optimal ROI covers that step, and the usual best move is to double down on the channel already working before you add anything new.

Take it into the leadership conversation

If you answer to a board or a leadership team, a benchmark is a gift, because it gives everyone a shared reference. Used badly, it turns into a ceiling or a rubber stamp: we're at the industry average, so we're fine. Average spending with average execution produces average results.

Bring three numbers instead of one: where you are, where peers are, and what closing the gap would buy.

Frame that gap in customers and revenue, not percentages. Leaders rarely rally around "we should spend two more points." They rally around "two more points on $3 million is $60,000, and at a $5,000 cost per customer that's about twelve more clients, and here's the channel we'd put them in." Keep an eye on the true cost of marketing too, so the full picture stays honest as the budget grows. Refresh the comparison once a year, and again whenever your revenue changes sharply, because the same dollar amount reads as a very different percentage when your revenue moves.

Do this week

Pick your comparison set, calculate your marketing allocation both ways, and place your numbers next to your industry average and the 7% floor. Then price the gap in dollars and clients using your cost per customer. If your sales cycle runs longer than 90 days, use 12 to 24 months of data so a short window doesn't mislead you.

Write the three numbers on one page and bring it to your next leadership meeting.

If you had to defend your marketing budget to a skeptical board tomorrow, would you lead with a benchmark or with your results?

If you'd like a second set of eyes on your marketing budget, reach out to us and we'll work through your comparison with you.

Contact Us

Recent Posts

Subscribe to the RevenueScaling Newsletter

Stay up to date on everything sales, including automation, hacks, reporting, tips and tricks, and more to scale your company.